Democracy and distrust book review

2709 mots 11 pages
Candidate ID number : 701

Book Report
Democracy and Distrust
John Hart Ely

The United States constitution is generally regarded as setting out two distinct sets of rules : procedural rules describing the functioning of the government and substantive rules setting out the fundamental rights the people retains against the government. Put another way, the procedural rules relate to the law making process and the substantive rules relate to the fundamental rights the laws cannot infringe. In Democracy and Distrust, Ely argues that the constitution is in fact overwhelmingly concerned with the law making process and that so called substantive rights should better be understood as merely necessary to the proper functioning of this law making process. Accordingly, Ely proposes a theory of judicial review where the role of the courts is limited to a review of the law making process - denying the courts any active role in the protection of justice or freedom and leaving it up to the government alone to weigh these ideals with its own idea of public interest.

At first, this view seems dangerous inasmuch as it prohibits the courts to second guess the government's democratic yet potentially liberticidal laws and fails to draw any conclusion from the second world war, which showed that democracies were not immune from totalitarian and racist behaviour. Indeed, Ely's view seems to go against the global trend of reinforcing courts' checks on governments (and peoples) in a desperate move to prevent similar atrocities from coming back up again. In fact, Democracy and Distrust came up in a completely different context, namely the judicial activism of the Warren court, which from 1953 to 1969 rendered some of the supreme court's most progressive decisions, ending racial segregation, extending the application of the Bill of Rights to the states and ending mandatory prayers in public schools. The hallmark of the Warren court was its departure from a textual interpretation of

en relation

  • Notes sur de la démocratie en amérique
    980 mots | 4 pages
  • La démocratie en questionnement
    4644 mots | 19 pages
  • Histoire de la justice au 18eme siècle
    7335 mots | 30 pages
  • Commentaire de l’arrêt du conseil d’etat de musique et autres domaines de musique
    1489 mots | 6 pages
  • Culture générale et expression de la fontaine
    1131 mots | 5 pages
  • La jurisprudence est-elle plus ou moins de lois ?
    1441 mots | 6 pages
  • Dissertation contrôle de constitutionnalité sous la vème république
    530 mots | 3 pages
  • Le juge constitutionnel et la protection des droits fondamentaux : suiveur ou innovateur ?
    1819 mots | 8 pages
  • Le domaine de la loi et du règlement sous la v ré rep
    2223 mots | 9 pages
  • TD8 le conseil constitutionnel
    1232 mots | 5 pages
  • Préambule de la constitution de 1848
    2424 mots | 10 pages
  • L'évolution de la Vème République
    1849 mots | 8 pages
  • Les modes de fonctionnement de la 5eme république
    8742 mots | 35 pages
  • Droit constat
    34163 mots | 137 pages
  • 1914 1918
    689 mots | 3 pages