Essai anglais - is it sometimes acceptable to break the law? - 263 mots

274 mots 2 pages
Is it sometimes acceptable to break the law?

It is a well-known fact that in some circumstances – in case of war, dictatorship, occupation, etc. – breaking the law can be, somehow considered acceptable. For instance, during World War 2, it cannot be denied that the ones who resisted Germany broke hundreds of laws but are still regarded as heroes because they also saved thousands of lives. However, the real question here is whether breaking the law can be admitted in everyday life extreme situations such as stealing money for food, or killing someone in a self defense case? As far as I am concerned, the law already answers this question. Cases of self defense are very well specified in the Penal Code as well as manslaughter cases. Attenuating circumstances also exist in law concerning thefts committed by needy persons. This way, a mother who steals bread to feed her children won’t probably be charged as much as a greedy billionaire who stole money from his clients. Therefore, we can see that in some cases even the law is flexible for something illegal. Yet, some tend to think this justice system is not fair since it is true that in certain circumstances, courts do make mistakes and condemn people who had no other choice than to break the law. However, I think that even if the sentence could be less strict, courts still have to judge these people because admitting one can break the law without getting trouble could lead the world into anarchy and chaos. For all these reasons I do not think that it is sometimes acceptable to do something

en relation

  • Plaidoyer contrefacon
    1361 mots | 6 pages
  • commentaire loi gombette
    2058 mots | 9 pages
  • Callicés, platon, commentaire
    738 mots | 3 pages
  • ECJS Majeurs
    408 mots | 2 pages
  • DM Philo Thomas d Aquin
    1270 mots | 6 pages
  • Dissertation sur le génocide du kilomètre-mort
    1014 mots | 5 pages
  • Fiche d'arrêt droit civil
    8221 mots | 33 pages
  • Commentaire article 1er code civil
    1698 mots | 7 pages
  • Fiche d'arrêt droit des obligations
    648 mots | 3 pages
  • Arrêt lacour de cassation
    2999 mots | 12 pages
  • Droit
    1144 mots | 5 pages
  • Commentaire d’arrêt : ce, 21 juin 2021, numéro 2121, numéro 42
    1418 mots | 6 pages
  • Le droit pénal de l'ancien régime
    10350 mots | 42 pages
  • droit
    1487 mots | 6 pages
  • Faut-il toujours obéir à la loi ?
    2890 mots | 12 pages