"We reject as false the choice between our safety and our ideals" discuss

280 mots 2 pages
American presidents have struggled with the balance between safety and civil liberties. But apparently, according to the Obama's inauguration speech that choice is false. The idea that no compromise is necessary between security and ideological commitments. But is it really true? Are those goals compatible?
Ever since the passage of the Bill of Rights, there has been a tension between individual liberty and the quest for a secure nation. On a number of occasions this balance has swung dramatically toward national security with the internment of Japanese Americans during the Second World War or with the McCarthy witch hunt and more recently with the Patriot Act.
Following the 9/11, congress passed this act as a mean for protecting the country against terrorism. No doubt that in tracking phone calls or e-mails communications this law poses threat to Americans' individual freedom. But according to Obama's speech, it's time to repeal the Patriot Act. As an example, Obama's first decision is to close Guantanamo and put an end of torture. At first glance it seems that Obamama upholds America's ideals.
But with one hand, Obama decided to close Guantanamo and end the abuse of detainees, and with the other he endorsed airstrikes against targets inside Pakistan. What sort of ideals does it take to conclude that causing the suffering of prisoners in the name of the national interest is wrong, but causing the suffering of civilians and the violation of Pakistan's sovereignty is right?
As a conclusion, half-steps won't do, what Obama has derided as a false choice is in truth the biggest choice he can make as a president.


en relation

  • Les mots de la santé
    65112 mots | 261 pages
  • Education
    72895 mots | 292 pages
  • Agile
    104969 mots | 420 pages
  • Ldp Meeting Point Tle
    195285 mots | 782 pages
  • Science and health with the key scripture
    203260 mots | 814 pages
  • Bac Sujets D Anglais Term LV1 LV2
    72485 mots | 290 pages
  • Relations internationales
    86404 mots | 346 pages
  • Coping
    105488 mots | 422 pages
  • Managing projects well
    59969 mots | 240 pages
  • The invention of culture -roy wagner
    76486 mots | 306 pages